Vital Football

Latest Wolverhampton Wanderers News

Should I Stay or Should I Go?

Should I Stay or Should I Go?

This week there has only been one question on the mind of Wolves bloggers: should we retain our manager or, if not, should he go now or at the end of the season? Judging from the deluge of responses and the strength of feeling aired, this is a highly emotive subject, as one would expect of an issue that affects the very existence of our beloved club as a Premier League outfit.
In the spirit of scientific enquiry, therefore, I have impartially surveyed all the blogs for the arguments for and against our manager and have listed them below. Because the format of Vital Wolves does not allow me to set the pros and cons against each other in parallel columns, I will first of all give the positive gloss and follow it up with the opposite view.

Pro: loyal to his players, especially those who put in a 'shift`. Con: prefers subservient work-horses to possibly temperamental stars in his transfer policy. With those at the club, favours certain individuals at the expense of the team and does not select players solely on merit.
Pro: determined and single-minded when convinced of a plan. Con: inflexible and stubborn; does not modify a plan quickly enough when it is found wanting (also see above).
Pro: honest and straight-talking. Con: does not readily admit to his mistakes, orally, in print or on the pitch.

Pro: survived last season with ease. Con: only did so because it was a relatively weak year. This season it will be far harder to survive.
Pro: the team is playing better this year. Con: we are five points worse off than in the equivalent matches last season.
Pro: linear forward movement since he became manager. Con: this season`s performances suggest that he has reached his managerial ceiling.
Pro: he eventually got it right last season. Con: yes, he did but the same tactics do not seem to be working this time round and it is beginning to look as though he does not know how to improve the situation.
Pro: he has made mistakes but everyone does. Con: good managers learn from their mistakes.
Pro: has had to contend with crucial injuries, especially to Zubar, Fletcher, Guedioura and now Henry. Con: this happens to every team and managers have to prepare for it by having suitable stand-ins, if required.
Pro: bedevilled by bad luck. Con: good and bad luck even themselves out over a period and render this excuse inadmissible. In fact, we have had plenty of good luck, as, for example, Piquionne`s disallowed goal for WHU.Even flukier, it was only as a result of 'bad` luck that Milijas returned to the team.

Pro: changing managers is counter-productive: it takes the new man time to get to know the club and its players, and it disrupts the team (Burnley, Hull). Con: a new manager can invigorate the team by coming without baggage and bringing in fresh ideas (Coyle at Bolton).
Pro: bringing in a new manager is risky as he might be worse than the current one (Hoddle). Con: in a crisis, a new manager might be the only way to save the club (Redknapp).
Pro: to change managers at this point in this season would be a mistake. Let`s wait to see if MM finds the answer. At least give him until after Christmas or even to the end of the season. Con: we need to change the club`s fortunes now by bringing in a new manager, one who can assess the club`s needs in time for the transfer window in January. It has to be someone with the status to attract new recruits of the requisite standard.
Pro: MM is a very experienced manager, having managed teams up to international level. He kept us up last year. Con: he has never done well at the highest levels. He failed at Sunderland because of shortage of funds but now looks as though he is going to fail at WWFC even with an abundance of money at his disposal.
Pro: he has brought in some good established players (Doyle, Fletcher and Milijas) and has had the nous to spot potential in others (Guedioura, Zubar and even Mujangi Bia, if the reports of the reserve match against Arsenal are any indication). Con: he has squandered millions on poor or over-rated players (JVD, Maierhoffer , Halford, Bent and now he is looking at Bagayoko, a non-scoring striker from Nice) and even when he buys potentially good players he either does not select them, leaves them on the bench or plays them in the wrong position (Milijas, Mouyokolo, Fletcher).

Pro: an experienced coach, especially of defenders. Con: really? So, why is defence the weakest part of the team, full, as it is, of non-Premier League standard players such as Berra, Elokobi, Stearman, Ward and even Foley. How come he cannot get them to do the basics right? Why has he not been able to find us a decent left back?
Pro: had the flash of inspiration (the inauguration of the 4-5-1 system) that saved us last year. Con: yes it did but it is not working that well this year. What we need now is goals as well as a solid defence and currently we are finding that difficult to achieve. We are not moving quickly enough out of defence, certainly not as well as Blackpool counter-attacked on Saturday.
Pro: started the season with the intention of playing more attacking football, hence the purchase of Fletcher to play alongside Doyle in a 4-4-2 formation. Con: this system requires a solid defence and was therefore quickly scrapped (along with Fletcher).
Pro: is capable of assessing the situation and will stumble on the solution. Con: even bloggers who write this do not really believe it. He obviously operates well at a certain level and with Championship players but lacks the flair or imagination to take the team to the next level. At the moment we would be happy if he took it to the level we finished at last year.
Pro: he motivates the players and has the respect of the dressing-room. Con: this is questionable. His favouritism and unwillingness to select players on merit surely erodes team-spirit. Indeed, signs of dissention and wanderlust are becoming apparent (Hahnemann, Hennessey, JVD, Jones).

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Wednesday November 24 2010
Time: 6:11PM


Nice one Banksy and congrats on becoming a "Journalist".
Crete Wolf
24/11/2010 19:53:00
not a bad summing up of all the pros and cons
24/11/2010 19:57:00
cant argue much of the above...
24/11/2010 20:12:00
Excellent breakdown of the various blogs and makes for good debates by supporters on both sides and I know which side I am on - McCarthy OUT! For me, McCarthy has done his best but quite clearly he has reached his limit in tactical ability, planning and the purchase of players and if allowed to continue he may well 'save the day' again but will we be content to see this happen season after season for surely Wolves fans and the board will not be happy to avoid relegation each season and not make any progression whatsoever?
25/11/2010 07:27:00
Nice Banksy, i think u just about covered the lot m8!! Unfortunately all of the above will mean a big fat zero if S'land turn us over. Fingers crossed. Lucky pants on. Beers in the fridge. I'm all set. UTW!
25/11/2010 13:47:00
Crete Wolf: is that a compliment? I'd rather own a bar in Crete!
25/11/2010 14:51:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Wolves Articles

Butti Out - Freedman Favourite?

Following quickly on the heels of Walter Zenga, general manager Andrea Butti has now also departed Wolverhampton Wanderers. Dougie Freedman is now the favourite to replace Zenga.

Wolves revolution needs to start again

Wolves have sacked manager Walter Zenga after results were not as good as expected

After Game Player Interviews Explained

Scientific researchers have discovered that a tendency for professional footballers to overuse the words 'um' 'ah' and 'err' in post game press interviews...

87 Days & Zenga's Off

Wolverhampton Wanderers have today confirmed that head coach Walter Zenga has been relieved of his duties at the Molineux following the most recent run of form.

Archived Vital Wolves Articles

Vital Wolves articles from

Site Journalists

no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Leeds MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Brito Teixeira5%
Sub - Cavaleiro0%
Sub - Coady5%
Sub - John5%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Newcastle 14 10 1 3 31 19
2 Brighton 14 8 4 2 28 9
3 Huddersfield 14 9 1 4 28 4
4 Norwich 14 8 3 3 27 7
5 Sheff Wed 14 7 3 4 24 1
6 Bristol City 14 7 2 5 23 6
7 Birmingham 14 6 5 3 23 3
8 Reading 14 6 4 4 22 -3
9 Preston 14 6 2 6 20 1
10 Leeds Utd 14 6 2 6 20 -1
11 Brentford 14 5 4 5 19 5
12 Barnsley 14 6 1 7 19 3
13 Q.P.R. 14 5 4 5 19 -3
14 Fulham 14 4 6 4 18 -2
15 Burton 14 4 5 5 17 0
16 Aston Villa 14 3 8 3 17 0
17 Ipswich 14 4 5 5 17 -2
18 Wolves 14 4 4 6 16 -1
19 Forest 14 4 3 7 15 -3
20 Cardiff 14 4 3 7 15 -9
21 Derby County 14 3 5 6 14 -4
22 Blackburn 14 3 3 8 12 -8
23 Wigan 14 2 5 7 11 -3
24 Rotherham 14 1 3 10 6 -19
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Wolves Results (view all)

Wolves Fixtures (view all)

Oct 29 2016 5:30PM : Blackburn Rovers (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Nov 5 2016 12:30PM : Derby County (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Nov 19 2016 3:00PM : Preston North End (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Nov 26 2016 3:00PM : Sheffield Wednesday (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Dec 1 2016 7:45PM : Queens Park Rangers (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Dec 10 2016 3:00PM : Fulham (H)
Sky Bet Championship

Vital Members League Table

Write for Vital Football